The performance was not enhanced but diminished by this distracting video counterpoint, which was unfair to composer, performers and listeners alike. Critical analysis of the wound dresser by walt whitman bartleby. Dive deep into walt whitmans the wounddresser with extended analysis, commentary, and discussion. A discussion of the wounddresser and leaves of grass wounddresser. The carol describes a honorable viewobject of the multitude and healers during the american civil engagement.
Through this description of sympathy and the vivid imagery whitman portrays through the wound dresser, one can learn various things about the civil war. Apr 25, 2018 in the wounddresser, whitman creates a dreamlike state of recollection. Unfortunately, the decision was made to accompany the wound dresser with multimedia projections of graphic photos of civil war dead and injured with maimed limbs and skulls. The wound dresser summary shmoop bestdressers 2019. In leaves of grass 1855, 18912, he celebrated democracy, nature, love, and friendship.
In walt whitmans poem, the wound dresser, the moments expressed throughout take place during the civil war and are experienced by an old, devoted wounddresser. The wounddresser the wounddresser by walt whitman 18191892 walt whitman the wounddresser by walt whitman 1 an old man bending i come among new faces, years looking backward resuming in answer to children, come tell us old man, as from young men and maidens that love me. Dec 05, 2008 the structure of the wounddresser, follows this successful style. Walt whitman, the dresser 1867, later titled the wound dresser whitman was fortytwo years old when the civil war started. But that doesnt mean it didnt exist, and whitman almost seems. The wound dresser is an intimate, graphic and deeply moving expression of the act of nursing the sick and dying. English test 2 emily dickinsons poetry 6 flashcards. A n old man bending i come among new faces, years looking backward resuming in answer to children, come tell us old man, as from young men and maidens that love. The wounddresser, by walt whitman, is a gruesome poem that brings his readers face to face with the cruel realities of war. The old poet is asked by the young to tell of his experience during the war. She was born in the industrial district of burslem, stokeontrent, staffordshire. Some critics would charge that he should have joined the union. In the wounddresser, initially entitled the dresser, an old man addresses young listeners asking about a war long past.
Literary analysis of the wounddresser by walt whitman. Affordable and search from millions of royalty free images, photos and vectors. Thus in silence in dreams projections, returning, resuming, i tread my way through. O maidens and young men i love, and that love me, what you ask of my days, those the strangest and sudden youre talking recalls. To delete a comment, just log in, and view the posts comments, there you will have the option to edit or delete them. Moreover, in section one there are two to three voices interwoven together. A discussion of the wounddresser and leaves of grass during the late romantic period, two of historys most profound poets, emily dickinson and walt whitman, emerged providing a foundation for, and a transition into modern poetry. Harold aspiz, wound dresser the 1865 criticism walt whitman. Compare and contrast dickinson and whitman mtakeyama93.
The wounddresser, by walt whitman is a short free verse poem that was written in 1865. In the wound dresser, initially entitled the dresser, an old man addresses young listeners asking about a war long past. A discussion of the wounddresser and leaves of grass. The specificity accumulates meaning as the poem unfolds. The ways in which whitman arrives at this depiction of equality, however, differ by poem. The wound dresser poem by walt whitman poem hunter. The wound dresser opening question imagine that you see people around injured and you try to help them but, everything you do, doesnt help. He represents the victims as an anonymous mass of sufferers and fails to label his patients according to the sides for which they fought. For example, a phrase like but a day or two more becomes two sixteenth notes, a triplet, and a half note, with a slight melodic rise on day or two to reflect that of the spoken phrase. Describes his rounds as war nurse treating battle wounds section 4. She left the city to study at st annes college, oxford, where she took a degree in english. The structure of the wounddresser, follows this successful style. The wounddresser is about the nurse talking about the fatally injured victims of civil war and how he had taken care of them. Equality in the wound dresser and song of myself anonymous college.
The piece is an elegiac setting of excerpts from american poet walt whitmans poem the wounddresser 1865 about his experience as a hospital volunteer during the american civil war it was written for baritone singer sanford sylvan, who premiered it on 24 february. Paul chamber orchestra under the direction of the composer. The wound dresser, by walt whitman, is a personal and relevant view of nurses during a time of war. Ah, now the single figure to me, amid all teeming and wealthy ohio, with all its cities and farms, sickly white in the face and dull in the head, very faint, by the jamb of a door leans. Whitman also describes the slave as limpsey and weak with a. The imagery illustrates that horses heads are symbolic of the speakers triumph over deaths grip. Whitmans poem is part of the series drumtaps, which treated civil war themes. Whitman remarks upon judgments that others make and refutes them with his own ideas of impartiality. The wounddresser an old man bending i come among new faces. The imagery illustrates the speakers view that horses are ghostly and intimidating animals that remind her of death. Provided to youtube by naxos of america the wounddresser sanford sylvan music for a time of war. The wound dresser is a setting for baritone voice and orchestra of a fragment from the poem of the same name. Equality in the wounddresser and song of myself the theme of equality. Walt whitman, the dresser 1867, later titled the wounddresser whitman was fortytwo years old when the civil war started.
An analysis of the wounddresser by walth whitman and. Walt whitmans the wounddresser is a sixtyfiveline freeverse poem in four sections describing the suffering in the civil war hospitals and the poets suffering, faithfulness to duty. First published in drumtaps as the dresser and given its present title in 1876, the wound dresser distills whitmans wartime hospital experiences and his urge to be the wars memorialist, to be witness again section 1, in an america reconciled in. Due to this, readers are able to create a war setting in their heads, based off the description of the medical tents and wounded soldiers in the war. An old man bending i come among new faces, years looking backward resuming in answer to children, come tell us old man, as from young men and maidens that love me, arousd and angry, id thought to beat the alarum, and urge relentless war. It is also astonishingly free of any kind of hyperbole or amplified emotion, yet the detail of the imagery is of a precision that could only be attained by one who had. Recognize the carol and retort the doubts control each. The setting of this poem is the nineteenth century around the time of the civil war. It is also astonishingly free of any kind of hyperbole or amplified emotion, yet the detail of the imagery is of a precision that could only be attained by one who had been there.
The wounddresser an old man bending i come among new faces an old man bending i come among new faces the academy of american poets is the largest membershipbased nonprofit organization fostering an appreciation for contemporary poetry and supporting american poets. The wounddresser was first performed in february 1989 by. Aug 01, 2017 walt whitman, the wounddresser, 1865 on july 21, 1861, spectators, armed with picnic baskets, eagerly followed the union army twenty five miles out of washington into the virginia countryside to watch what would become the first major battle of the american civil war. If youre trying to analyze walt whitmans i hear america singing, and beat. The wounddresser is one of walt whitmans most famous poems, published in 1865 in his collection drum taps. As always with whitman, it is in the first person, and it is the most intimate, most graphic and most profoundly affecting evocation of the act of nursing the sick and the dying that i know of. With my whole heart, with my whole life, and with my innermost being, i bow in wonder and love before you, the holy god. Walt whitman published the wounddresser, which became one of his most famous poems, in 1865. The wound dresser, jack coulehans sixth collection of poems, explores the mysterious tension between tenderness and steadiness in medical practice. Equality in the wounddresser and song of myself the theme of equality permeates both the wounddresser and song of myself. The poem consists of four sections and sixtyfive lines.
Soldier alert i arrive, after a long march, coverd with sweat and dust whitman line 2. Through the vehicles of imagery and repetition, whitman creates a certain tone for each work, which. Although walt whitman wrote the poem in 1865, he first published the wounddresser in the 1876 edition of leaves of grass, a poetry collection that appeared in several. The narrator in the wound dresser carries many qualities. Compare and contrast dickinson and whitman mtakeyama93s blog. You can talk about some of the form elements, for example. These manifest particularly strongly in whitmans attitude towards the bravery of soldiers in the wounddresser and section 18 of. The poem is remarkable for its lack of exaggerated portrayals of pain and suffering. Jan 31, 2011 compare and contrast dickinson and whitman mr wordpress. The wounddresser is a setting of most of the poem of the same name by walt whitman. Aug 05, 2014 walt whitman, the wound dresser online text the poem describes a rare viewpoint of the soldiers and healers during the american civil war. Adams composed the wounddresser in the late 1980s, during the height of the aids crisis, and although its imagery is specific to the civil war, it achieves a sense of universal suffering.
Whitman also describes the slave as limpsey and weak with a sweated body and bruised feet. They both use personification, metaphors, and repetition to emphasize the meaning behind their poetry. Tells of experience as soldier, not as memorable as wounded section 3. He begins the poem with a broad illustration of soldiers in masses and, with each progressing section, tightens the scene to an intimate image of one boys struggle with death. Jun 17, 2016 adams composed the wound dresser in the late 1980s, during the height of the aids crisis, and although its imagery is specific to the civil war, it achieves a sense of universal suffering. I dress the perforated shoulder, the foot with the bulletwound, cleanse the one with a gnawing and putrid gangrene, so sickening, so offensive, while the attendant stands behind aside me holding the tray and pail. Critical analysis of the wound dresser by walt whitman. This literary analysis of walt whitman poems dives into what made whitman so iconic from his use of free form to his love for ordinary people. Equality in the wound dresser and song of myself the theme of equality permeates both the wound dresser and song of myself. This was his indoctrination to the ghastly consequences of warfare. Like unbroken, the wound dresser is about a war the civil war in whitmans case that happened before the term ptsd became common knowledge.
Equality in the wounddresser and song of myself anonymous college. It is also astonishingly free of any kind of hyperbole or amplified emotion, yet the detail of the imagery is of a precision that could only be attained by one who had been. Whitmans wound dresser homework sarah lembo professor. It gives a graphic yet unsentimental view of war and the inglamorous side of what. The wounddresser by walt whitman poetry foundation. The wound dresser is a classic poem about taking care of people who are sick and dying. Sentences brokengunshot wound in the breast, cavalry skirmish, taken to hospital, at present low, but will soon be better. Literary analysis of the wounddresser by walt whitman bartleby.
Walt whitman and the civil war american experience. On the granite walls of the dupont circle metro station in washington, d. Read further to find a summary of its four sections. The wounddresser, says adams, is the most intimate, most graphic, and most profoundly affecting evocation of the act of nursing the sick and dying that i know of. An analysis of the wounddresser by walth whitman and success is counted sweetest by emily dickinson pages 2. When you write a summary or work with the text in any other way, using these four sections as a. The wounddresser by walt whitman about this poet walt whitman is americas world poeta latterday successor to homer, virgil, dante, and shakespeare. These manifest particularly strongly in whitmans attitude towards the bravery of soldiers in the wound dresser and section 18 of song of myself.
Whitman remarks upon judgments that others make and. A discussion of the wounddresser and leaves of grass essay. A discussion of the wounddresser and leaves of grass wound. Walt whitman, the wounddresser poem questions and sample. Whitmans wound dresser status displays great love for the individuals he watched over. The wound dresser is a series of letters written from the hospitals in washington by walt whitman during the war of the rebellion to the new york times, the brooklyn eagle and his mother, edited by richard maurice burke, m. Adams, however, has recreated the rhythms of whitmans wounddresser so that the poem retains its integrity. The poem begins with the wound dresser having to make a choice on whether he should tell a group of children what he went through or silently watch the dead 17.
Punctuation rhetorical questions where their priceless blood reddens the grass, the. The wound dresser walt whitman poem dissection section 1. Little critical attention has been paid to the poems which follow the climactic the wound dresser, in large part because they eschew the deep conflicts addressed in early poems of drumtaps and the direct encounter with the war and its victims that the central poems in the sequence take for their subject. Garland publishing, 1998, reproduced by permission. Hampson brings intense advocacy to adams wound dresser. Walt whitman, the wounddresser, 1865 on july 21, 1861, spectators, armed with picnic baskets, eagerly followed the union army twenty five miles out of washington into the virginia countryside to watch what would become the first major battle of the american civil war. Librivox recording of the wound dresser, by walt whitman. The theme of equality permeates both the wound dresser and song of myself. For example, whitman personifies america singing in i hear america singing and dickinson personifies death in because i could. Scored for baritone and orchestra, the work was written in 1989 and premiered that year by sanford sylvan and the st. Yet, the attention to detail, the depiction of images, etc. At original a proponent control the engagement, walt whitmonstrosity. This monumental work chanted praises to the body as well as to the soul, and found beauty and. Through the vehicles of imagery and repetition, whitman creates a certain tone.
Poetic features like parallelism, the catalog, and free verse give the wounddresser and other poems from the drumtaps section in leaves of grass a sweeping, serious power, which suits the. The wound dresser takes on the prophet persona utilizing dream imagery, and describes the darker side of the soldiers that the children long to hear aboutthose that have faced gangrene and amputation. The wounddresser, adams explains, is the most intimate, most graphic, and most profoundly affecting evocation of the act of nursing the sick and dying that i know of. Emily dickinson and walt whitman both have poetry that give the readers a message about certain aspects of life and death. Soldier alert i arrive, after a long march, coverd with sweat and. The children in the story ask the veteran to tell them some of his old war stories. When you write a summary or work with the text in any. Read further to find a summary of its four sections and quotes from the poem. The wound dresser frequently confuses students because of the repeated use of an interior monologue which is set off by placing the narrators thoughts in parenthesis. Surprised at his own conflicted feelings about his role as a physician, coulehan seeks to emulate the tender care shown by walt whitman as he comforted wounded civil war soldiers. He the narrator focuses on the suffering he sees, but the poem is still in many ways. In silence and in dreams, he returns to the battlefield. At first a proponent for the war, walt whitman soon came to comprehend the pain and suffering of the soldiers and devoted himself to helping and comforting them as a volunteer nurse.
Walt whitmans 1865 poem the wounddresser is a moving response to the destructiveness of the american civil war, one influenced by the. In on reading walt whitmans the wound dresser coulehan sees whitman as a nurse tending the civil war wounded, and, while using some of the words and language of whitmans poem, imagines himself moving forward in that created space of caring for. The wounddresser is one of whitmans most famous works. The imagery introduces the idea that death is a natural and ordinary part of ones journey through life. There are many different angles you can take in analyzing it for an assignment. Whitman rushed from brooklyn to the washington area to search the hospitals and encampments for george.
In walt whitmans poem, the wound dresser, the moments expressed throughout take place during the civil war and are experienced by an old. The wounddresser is a nineteenminutelong piece by u. Walt whitman, the wounddresser online text the poem describes a rare viewpoint of the soldiers and healers during the american civil war. Bearing the bandages, water and sponge, straight and swift to my wounded i go, where they lie on the. The collection is prefaced and named for a poem by walt whitman, the wound dresser, annotated in this database by jack coulehan. The wounddresser, by walt whitman, is a poem that was written in 1865. An old man bending i come among new faces the academy of american poets is the largest membershipbased nonprofit organization fostering an appreciation for contemporary poetry and supporting american poets.
1207 807 1120 1373 181 1563 715 382 671 938 1473 1246 1557 1372 1024 702 41 724 1114 300 20 399 454 1452 733 519 183 1623 861 942 1025 1417 1392 1372 406 732 1342 106 1237 587 520 750 1396 1352 567